Where to Buy Olive Loaf in Westchester County, NY (and How to Find It Anywhere)
Where to Buy Olive Loaf in Westchester County, NY (and How to Find It Anywhere)
Olive loaf, a pink, mild lunch meat studded with sliced green olives and bits of pimiento, was a deli staple for decades. It’s less common now, so finding it takes a little strategy. This guide shows where to look in Westchester, how to ask for it, and what to do if no store carries it.
Step 1: Check Local Delis and Butcher Counters First
What to do: Start with places that slice deli meat to order.
How to do it: Independent Italian and Jewish-style delis, butcher shops, and the deli counters of larger grocers are your best bet. Call ahead and ask, “Do you carry olive loaf, or olive and pimento loaf?” Stores often stock it quietly even when it isn’t on the visible menu. Westchester has many long-standing delis and specialty markets in towns like Yonkers, New Rochelle, White Plains, and Mount Vernon, which are good places to begin. Hours and stock change, so confirm by phone.
Common mistake to avoid: Searching only by the name “olive loaf.” Some stores list it as “olive and pimento loaf,” “pickle and pimento,” or simply a “specialty loaf.”
Step 2: Try Supermarket Deli Counters and Prepackaged Aisles
What to do: Check the chain grocers and the refrigerated lunch meat section.
How to do it: Ask at the deli counter of large supermarkets and warehouse clubs. Also look in the prepackaged lunch meat aisle, where national and regional brands sometimes sell olive loaf in sliced packs. Many chains offer an online store locator or inventory search, so you can check whether a nearby location has it in stock before driving.
Common mistake to avoid: Giving up after one store. Stock varies by location, so check two or three.






